Welcome to Transportation Law Today
Managed by Paul J. Loftus, a partner at Dinsmore & Shohl LLP, Transportation Law Today provides professionals in the rail, transit, inland maritime, and trucking industries with current news and analysis of laws, rulings, and regulatory policies.
Showing posts with label Hazardous Materials Transportation Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hazardous Materials Transportation Act. Show all posts
Tuesday, February 12, 2013
Increased Rail Haz Mat Penalties Published
The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA), published today revised civil monetary penalties for the violation of the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act. The FRA rule implements the increased penalties enacted in July 2012 with the passage of the MAP-21 Act (Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act).
The increased penalties, which apply to all violations of the federal haz mat transportation laws after October 1, 2012, increase the maximum civil penalty from $50,000 to $75,000 for "knowing violations," and from $100,000 to $175,000 if the violation "results in death, serious injury or severe injury to any person, or substantial destruction of property." Also, the prior minimum penalty of $250 has been eliminated, except that a $450 minimum penalty will apply to training violations.
Tuesday, July 3, 2012
PHMSA Rules Tort Claim for Haz Mat Package Warning Preempted
The USDOT's Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) issued a ruling, published in today's Federal Register, which preempts a common law tort action for design, manufacture and marking (including warnings) for a haz mat package.
The underlying event was the explosion of a DOT specification 39 cylinder, which exploded in January 2003 when placed in 180 deg. water. The explosion killed Kenneth Elder, whose survivors brought a product liability action against the cylinder manufacturer.
PHMSA's ruling came after the manufacturer petitioned the agency to make a preemption ruling on the underlying tort claims. The Hazardous Materials Transportation Act gives the agency authority to make such rulings, under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d).
Under the HMTA, claims relating to design, manufacture and labeling are preempted if the "non-federal requirement (i.e. a lawsuit seeking to impose an additional warning) is not "substantively the same" as federal regulation under the haz mat act. This is a somewhat different standard than preemption under the Federal Rail Safety Act (FRSA) - 49 U.S.C. 20106 - which permits more stringent state regulation covering the same subject matter as federal rail regulations if the state regulation is meant to address a local safety hazard and does not burden interstate commerce.
PHMSA determined that any "state requirement, including a State's common law" which is not substantively the same as the federal regulations on the design, manufacturing, or marking of a haz mat package is preempted, and thus, the underlying claim that Mr. Elder's death was a result of an improper design, marking, or warning of the cylinder was preempted. PHMSA did emphasize, however, that the HMTA preemption provision does not insulate anyone from violating a haz mat regulation or when the packaging does not conform to a specification under the haz mat regulations.
The procedure utilized by the defendant manufacturer, filing an administrative petition with PHMSA seeking a preemption ruling, is interesting. Unlike the FRSA, the HMTA specifically permits PHMSA to make a preemption decision on the legal claims brought Mr. Elder's survivors. So, in effect, an administrative agency has made a preemption decision which presumably will end a legal case pending in the Courts.
The underlying event was the explosion of a DOT specification 39 cylinder, which exploded in January 2003 when placed in 180 deg. water. The explosion killed Kenneth Elder, whose survivors brought a product liability action against the cylinder manufacturer.
PHMSA's ruling came after the manufacturer petitioned the agency to make a preemption ruling on the underlying tort claims. The Hazardous Materials Transportation Act gives the agency authority to make such rulings, under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d).
Under the HMTA, claims relating to design, manufacture and labeling are preempted if the "non-federal requirement (i.e. a lawsuit seeking to impose an additional warning) is not "substantively the same" as federal regulation under the haz mat act. This is a somewhat different standard than preemption under the Federal Rail Safety Act (FRSA) - 49 U.S.C. 20106 - which permits more stringent state regulation covering the same subject matter as federal rail regulations if the state regulation is meant to address a local safety hazard and does not burden interstate commerce.
PHMSA determined that any "state requirement, including a State's common law" which is not substantively the same as the federal regulations on the design, manufacturing, or marking of a haz mat package is preempted, and thus, the underlying claim that Mr. Elder's death was a result of an improper design, marking, or warning of the cylinder was preempted. PHMSA did emphasize, however, that the HMTA preemption provision does not insulate anyone from violating a haz mat regulation or when the packaging does not conform to a specification under the haz mat regulations.
The procedure utilized by the defendant manufacturer, filing an administrative petition with PHMSA seeking a preemption ruling, is interesting. Unlike the FRSA, the HMTA specifically permits PHMSA to make a preemption decision on the legal claims brought Mr. Elder's survivors. So, in effect, an administrative agency has made a preemption decision which presumably will end a legal case pending in the Courts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)